CGHA recently criticized Palau’s position on international nicotine prohibition. Part of the concern was the influence a tiny country could exercise within an international process promoting bad policies far beyond its shores.
Well, two can play at that game.
Malta, another small island state, has demonstrated that this influence can work in the other direction. On November 9, it withheld support for the European Union’s tobacco taxation package. The other 26 member states were prepared to proceed. Because EU tax legislation requires unanimity, Malta’s refusal prevented agreement.
Three cheers for Malta.
The lesson is straightforward. A country’s size tells us little about the wisdom of its intervention. Small governments can advance foolish policies, and they can obstruct them. Malta has performed a valuable service.
The proposed package would increase minimum cigarette taxes and extend the EU excise framework to products including e-cigarettes and nicotine pouches. Its supporters describe this as modernizing outdated rules and protecting public health.
There is nothing inherently unreasonable about taxing cigarettes at a relatively high rate. Smoking imposes substantial health risks, and a reasonable cigarette tax can raise revenue while discouraging consumption. The question is how to design that tax without defeating its purpose.
Two principles should guide the answer.
First, products with far lower health risks should face far lower taxes. Vapes and nicotine pouches deliver nicotine without burning tobacco. Their fiscal treatment should reflect that fundamental distinction. If governments want smokers to switch away from cigarettes, the tax system should reinforce the incentive to do so.
Putting different products into a common tax framework does not necessarily mean taxing them equally. But extending taxation to lower-risk alternatives requires a clear justification for the rates chosen and careful attention to how those rates affect switching. A government can discourage smoking or make its substitutes less affordable. Doing both creates an obvious tension.
Second, taxes can be too high. Consumers do not respond only by quitting. They can buy across borders, seek illicit supplies, or move into markets where age restrictions, product standards, and tax collection are largely absent. Beyond a certain point, higher rates undermine both the revenue objective and the health rationale.
Precisely where that point lies varies between countries and products. That is a reason for caution about imposing higher minimum rates across economies with different incomes, existing taxes, and exposure to illicit trade. The EU risks pushing taxes toward levels that strengthen the very markets its governments claim to oppose.
Malta’s finance minister, Clyde Caruana, has warned that the proposed minimum rates would have disproportionate effects in Malta. He has also defended national authority over taxation and criticized arrangements that constrain flexibility to reflect domestic circumstances.
He is right to challenge the package. Malta need not have embraced every argument for tobacco harm reduction to deserve enormous credit. Even if its objection principally serves its own fiscal interests, resisting a poorly designed tax proposal can produce benefits beyond its borders.
The revenue question also deserves scrutiny. Alongside the tax reform, the European Commission proposes a tobacco excise-based contribution to the EU budget. The European Court of Auditors has warned that successful reductions in tobacco consumption could undermine the revenue expected from that funding stream. It also explains that the arrangement would reduce revenue otherwise retained by member states.
That does not invalidate tobacco taxation. It does expose the tension between discouraging consumption and building spending commitments around its continuation.
Malta has delayed this package, not defeated it permanently. The opportunity should be used to demand taxes that reflect relative risks and realistic assessments of illicit trade.
CGHA’s objection to Palau concerned the policy it promoted. The same standard requires applauding Malta for obstructing a bad one. When a small island stands in the way of an illogical international agenda, its size is no reason to dismiss it.
Sometimes it takes one government saying no to make 26 others think again.


